Content of review 1, reviewed on November 18, 2025
This study adapts the existing “BioSorp Beads” platform to address nitrate pollution in urban stormwater, a key limitation of conventional green stormwater infrastructure (GSI) due to nitrate’s poor sorption to soil and particle independence. The authors encapsulate anion exchange resin (AER) for nitrate sorption, anaerobic denitrifying microorganisms (enriched from wastewater sludge), iron minerals (electron donors), wood flour (carbon source), and powdered activated carbon (PAC, for trace organics and biofilm support) in calcium alginate beads. Key findings: AER is critical for nitrate sorption (up to 1.32 mg/g in synthetic stormwater); calcium alginate beads outperform ferric alginate beads (circumneutral pH vs. acidic ~3.5, optimizing denitrification); wood flour boosts denitrification efficiency by 80%; beads achieve near-complete nitrate removal (< detection limit) within a week under both anaerobic and bulk aerobic conditions; high ionic strength (e.g., road salt) reduces sorption but does not negate overall performance. The work demonstrates a scalable, retrofittable solution for GSI to decouple hydraulic retention time and contaminant residence time via “sorption during storms + biodegradation during dry periods.”
________________________________________
Comments for Improvement
1. Elaborate Microbial Community Characterization: The manuscript attributes denitrification to encapsulated mixed microbes but lacks insights into community composition (e.g., key denitrifying taxa) and dynamics. Adding high-throughput sequencing data would validate the role of facultative anaerobes and explain resilience under aerobic conditions, strengthening mechanistic understanding.
2. Supplement Pilot-Scale and Long-Term Stability Data: Lab-scale results are promising, but field applicability requires pilot tests in actual bioretention cells. Include data on bead durability (e.g., hydraulic stress resistance, biodegradation over multiple storm-dry cycles) and sorption-regeneration cycles to demonstrate long-term service life—critical for engineering adoption.
3. Address High-Ionic-Strength Mitigation: While the authors note reduced sorption under high ionic strength (winter road salt), no mitigation strategies are proposed. Suggest testing bead modifications (e.g., more nitrate-selective AER, cation-competing ligands) or deployment strategies (e.g., placement in low-salt-flow zones) to enhance winter performance.
4. Strengthen Comparative Analysis: Contrast BioSorp Beads with existing nitrate mitigation technologies (e.g., saturated underdrains, woodchip bioreactors, biochar amendments) in terms of cost, space requirements, retrofitting feasibility, and nitrate removal efficiency. This contextualizes the technology’s unique value for GSI.
5. Refine Kinetic and Mechanistic Modeling: The sorption model (modified Langmuir) focuses on abiotic processes, but a coupled sorption-denitrification kinetic model (integrating AER desorption and microbial activity) would better predict real-world performance and guide bead optimization (e.g., AER/microbe ratio).
6. Clarify PAC’s Role in Nitrate Removal: PAC is included for trace organics and biofilm support, but its potential indirect impact on nitrate removal (e.g., altering microenvironment, reducing toxic co-contaminants) is not discussed. Clarify whether PAC enhances denitrification beyond biofilm attachment to justify its inclusion in the bead recipe.
Source
© 2025 the Reviewer.
Content of review 2, reviewed on August 05, 2026
This revision comprehensively addresses every substantial reviewer critique, structurally reframes the work to eliminate overreach of lab-scale findings, improves experimental transparency via added controls/statistics/SI, and strengthens the paper’s novelty and alignment with Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology scope. The resubmitted manuscript is now to be recommended acceptanct in current form.
Source
© 2026 the Reviewer.
Content of review 3, reviewed on October 03, 2026
The reviewer appreciates the author's careful and sincere revision of the manuscript. All concerns raised in the first review have been adequately addressed.
Source
© 2026 the Reviewer.
References
S., T. D., H., L. G. Encapsulating Sorptive Materials and Anaerobic Microorganisms in Composite Alginate Bead Geomedia to Capture and Biodegrade Nitrate in Green Stormwater Infrastructure. Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology.
