Comments on draft CQG-111588"\\Can a radiation gauge be horizon-locking?".\
*************\
Dear Editor,

In this note, there is an attempt to address the connection between horizon locking demand and radiation gauge in the context of black hole perturbation theory. The motivation is interesting and calculations are straightforward. I just have a few suggestions and am inclined to recommend acceptance of the paper.\
\

Firstly, regarding the concept of horizon-locking, it would be beneficial to provide a more detailed and focused explanation. Enhancing the clarity surrounding this concept will enrich the understanding of readers.\
\

Secondly, concerning the conclusion, I advocate for a succinct and explicit summary at the conclusion of the paper. This summary should clearly delineate the criteria under which the question posed can be answered affirmatively, as well as specify the methodology employed.\
\

Lastly, there is a discrepancy regarding the symbol "v" in Eq. (3), which appears to be undefined in the note. \
\
I trust these suggestions will improve the quality and comprehensibility of the paper.\

\

Sincerely.\

Dear Editor, I am pleased with the modifications and accept the present version.