I am serving as a data editor for this manuscript. Intermediate data produced from the simulation model are provided, as well as the code to produce the manuscript figures. At this time, I believe this is all that is required. Ideally, the simulation code used to create the median\_phenologies\_... files would also be available to help spur further development and ensure reproducibility, but these simulation codes might already be deposited somewhere else.

Fig.S1.r produces FigS10.pdf but it's not Fig S10. This doesn't _really_ matter, but thought I'd point it out. Using . in filenames is also generally not recommended. Neither is starting an R script by removing everything in the workspace, but this is not something that strictly needs to be changed for this work to proceed onward.

Otherwise, I have no other comments. Thank you for your work.