Content of review 1, reviewed on November 08, 2022

In "Evasion differential game of many pursuers and one evader for an infinite system of binary differential equations" the authors present us with a differential game, formally well delineated, which they then solve in Theorem 1 through a constructive proof, in which they create strategies for the evader and the pursuers. Formally, from a mathematical point of view, it seems ok. Now let's look at the problems: -The text is full of grammatical errors: confusion in the use of the comparative and the superlative; wrong subject and verb concordances; words misused,..., In short, it is necessary to carry out a profound revision of English. -The first section, without title, must be titled. I think it would be fine 1. Introduction (the following ones being renumbered accordingly). In this section there is a literature review, very clumsy, uncritical, in which many references appear treated to packages. Possibly, each package could be represented by just one. If not, they cannot be packaged. A thorough review is needed here. Otherwise it seems that the authors just wanted to fill the bibliography. There is also a need to make more comments, and in a critical way. -As for the problem, the center of this text, it is necessary to know if it was created by the authors or inspired by other sources. In any case, a real-life situation must be set that matches the problem (in fact, the authors claim that many real-life situations can formalize these problems). This would help a lot to understand the formalization and to feel better about the strategies created. The blunt presentation of mathematical formalization fails on these points and is a disincentive to readers. Without these corrections, it is very difficult to make a correct assessment of the paper, and to give an opinion on its possible publication in Mathematics.

Source

    © 2022 the Reviewer (CC BY 4.0).

Content of review 2, reviewed on November 18, 2022

The text has evidently improved, not as much as I would have liked, but enough that it could be published in Mathematics. I only asked the authors to give due prominence to their main result.

Source

    © 2022 the Reviewer (CC BY 4.0).

References

    Gafurjan, I., Ruzakhon, K., Antonio, P. B. 2022. Evasion Differential Game of Multiple Pursuers and One Evader for an Infinite System of Binary Differential Equations. Mathematics.