Post-publication Review of
Reviewed On June 14, 2014
Reviewed by
Endorsed by
Content of review 1, reviewed on June 14, 2014

Following presentation by Eugene d'Eon of the paper in Prague I can recall two questions:

1) Ravi Ramamoorthi: "It seems that there is an analogous relationship between the Marschner model and the spherical Gaussian M function in your paper much like the difference between Blinn Phong and Phong specular lobes for surfaces". Response: "Hmmm, I'm not sure."

2) Marcos Fajardo: "We found an importance sampling scheme for the Marschner model. Can you comment on importance sampling for your new model?" Response: "No, haven't thought about it." (However, a method was later published in a SIGGRAPH 2013 technical brief that importance samples it completely and analytically).


    © 2014 the Reviewer.

Comments   (Guidelines)

Please log in to leave a comment.


    Eugene, d., Guillaume, F., Martin, H., Joe, L., Jean-Marie, A. 2011. An Energy-Conserving Hair Reflectance Model. Computer Graphics Forum.