Content of review 1, reviewed on January 07, 2024

The main contribution of the study is the introduction of the new dimensionless number Na.

Could you clarify if the model performs well for angles less than -30 degrees to vertical downward flow? Also, it is recommended to discuss further how using other correlations could affect the proposed model's accuracy.

Source

    © 2024 the Reviewer.

Content of review 2, reviewed on April 30, 2024

Very good work and showed a detailed comparison between all available models. The proposed model showed more accurate prediction than the available ones
In figure 6 the box of Start /Data lecture isn’t it “vs” the slip velocity which is unknown, why input.
In the same box what is E exactly? you wrote Tol=0.001 thenE=100 then you defined E as the difference between the old and new HLS why start with E=100 ?
A new correlation for the liquid slug holdup HLs has been proposed in the paper "Novel Correlations for the Liquid Holdup in a Gas-Liquid Slug Flow" published in Geoenergy Science and Engineering in 2024. Can you compare it with other correlations?

Source

    © 2024 the Reviewer.

References

    Gabriel, S., Eduardo, P., Cem, S. 2024. Unified closure relationship for slug liquid holdup. The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering.