Content of review 1, reviewed on March 09, 2021
Review Manuscript ID: symmetry-1151647 Type of manuscript: Article Title: Inverse scattering and soliton solutions of nonlocal complex reverse-spacetime modified Korteweg-de Vries hierarchies Authors: Liming Ling, Wen-Xiu Ma* Submitted to the section: Mathematics and Symmetry, Nonlocal Partial Differential Equations, Methods and Applications Date: 9 March 2021
The manuscript describes the inverse scattering aspect for the mKdV equation. It is well-written and should be recommended for publication. Here are some remarks.
You may now transfer the typeset into the MDPI LaTeX template as the recommendation for this article is going to be positive.
Five affiliations for one of the authors are too many and suspicious. Even some Nobel prize winners only hold one or two affiliations at one time.
The keyword mentioned parity-time symmetry, but it was not discussed in the text.
The citation should be written as follows: [2-7] and [10-14].
The size of the matrices on pages 2 and 3 is not specified. The readers interpret it as 2 x 2. However, after going to Section 2, it becomes n x n. What is even more confusing, on page 6, the matrix operator \Psi has the size of (2n) x (2n). Please clarify this matter.
On page 21, the authors re-discovered one-soliton solution for the mKdV equation. I am sure that this solution is already available in the literature. So, what is then the contribution of this paper apart from a different, rather detour approach in recovering the soliton solutions? Furthermore, the authors mentioned N-soliton solutions of the mKdV equation, but these solutions are not stated and expressed explicitly. Is that any reason for that?
On page 20, the phrase "as normal" seems weird. Please reword it.
Source
© 2021 the Reviewer.
