Content of review 1, reviewed on August 25, 2022

The title of this work: "Computational Analysis of XLindley Parameters Using Adaptive Type-II Progressive Hybrid Censoring With Applications in Chemical Engineering" has the great virtue of accurately describing its objective. The authors begin by posing the problem they intend to study and analyze, and they do so in an exemplary way. In fact, they do not neglect any scientific or technical aspect, facing all difficulties in a determined way. They also indicate the reasons, both of a more technical and more practical nature, that justify carrying out this study. This is done simultaneously with a review of the literature in which the works considered appear purposefully in the various stages of this part of the text. Also in the Introduction, the authors emphasize the innovative nature of their approach. Obviously it ends with the description of the text structure. In the next two sections, they analyze the "Classical inference", and the "Bayes MCMC paradigm", respectively. Here they implicitly make a comparison between the two situations, which gives the advantage of the "Bayes MCMC paradigm". It is also worth noting, in relation to the latter, the algorithm presented, which is clearly useful. Next are the Monte Carlo simulations, very careful to assess the behavior of the proposed estimators of the unknown parameters, determined in the previous sections. Then we have the real-life applications, in the field of chemistry (interesting problems are considered in this field). And, finally, the very well presented conclusions resulting directly from the previous text. Very interesting, publish as is.

Source

    © 2022 the Reviewer (CC BY 4.0).

References

    Refah, A., Mazen, N., Ahmed, E. 2022. Computational Analysis of XLindley Parameters Using Adaptive Type-II Progressive Hybrid Censoring with Applications in Chemical Engineering. Mathematics.