Content of review 1, reviewed on September 17, 2018
Technically, this paper is of high caliber because it follows a streamlined research approach abiding by the highest standards when dealing with human participants beside the adequate literature review and the very clear methodology and statistical analyses followed. From a social perspective, the topic is of high importance because it deals with health problems considred popular worldwide affecting the lives of so many children carrying Asthma cases just because of the behaviour of their parents. As the Arabic proverb posits, "the parents eat sour grapes, and the kids suffer the acidity consequneces!". This paper adds concrete evidence about the impact of smoking by the praents on kids [though the authors expose minor limitations to clinical data used]. Further research is needed and hopefull future research treats the kids [children] gender as a moderating factor.
Source
© 2018 the Reviewer (CC BY 4.0).
References
Simone, A., Lucia, C., Ane, J., Laura, P., Bryndis, B., Jacobsen, B. R., Lennart, B., Anne-Elie, C., C., D. S., Julia, D., Bertil, F., Gomez, R. F., Joachim, H., W., H. J., Mathias, H., Christer, J., Rain, J., Benedicte, L., Andrei, M., Alessandro, M., Jesus, M. R., Chantal, R., Jose, L. S., Vivi, S., Roberto, B., G., C. A., Pascal, D., Sandra, D. A., Dennis, N., Isabelle, P., Joost, W., Deborah, J., Cecilie, S. 2018. A three-generation study on the association of tobacco smoking with asthma. International Journal of Epidemiology.