Content of review 1, reviewed on December 10, 2022

The authors aimed to quantitatively analyze perineural invasion (PNI) in oral
squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) specimens. There are some points need to be addressed.

  1. In the Abstract section, the authors mentioned “Patients with M1 disease and those with synchronous or metachronous cancer were excluded.” However, the authors included patients who had died from a second primary cancer. A second primary cancer is also a metachronous cancer. Please make a revision.
  2. In the Abstract section, the authors mentioned “In multivariate analysis, clinical T4 or N2 stage were still significantly correlated with poor OS, …..” However, in the Result section, the authors mentioned “Pathological T4 stage and pathological N2 stage correlated with OS in the univariate analysis (P < 0.05). Pathological N2 stage was the only independent prognostic factor in the multivariate analysis (P < 0.05).” Please make a revision.
  3. In which slide do the authors choose to record PNI? As we know that PNI may be distributed unevenly throughout the tumor. Please make a very clear description in the Materials and Methods section.
  4. Please provide the representative S100 staining IPNI and EPNI figures.
  5. Surprisingly, the 3-year recurrence-free survival (RFS) rates of all patients was 81.2%, almost the same with the 3-year OS rates of all patients. Most previous studies have defined RFS as “the time from date of curative surgery to the time of recurrence or death”. In other words, if a patient died without recurrence during postoperative follow-up, it should be considered as an end point for RFS but not a censored event. The authors actually adopted time-to-recurrence (TTR, which is generally defined as “the time from date of curative surgery to the time of recurrence) rather than RFS in this study. Please make a revision.
  6. The authors may consider to add disease-specific survival or disease-free survival in the survival analyses.
  7. In Table 1 and 2, the authors had shown the data of skin invasion, bone invasion, and DOI. These data are already shown as “pathologic T stage”. Please delete the redundant information.
  8. In Table 2, about the location of p value, please put it in another column to make the table 2 more readable.

Source

    © 2022 the Reviewer.

Content of review 2, reviewed on February 14, 2023

The authors aimed to quantitatively analyze perineural invasion (PNI) in oral
squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) specimens. The quality and readability of the revised manuscript has been improved after revision. There are still some points need to be addressed.

  1. In the Abstract section, the authors make a revision to as follows: “Patients with M1 disease and those with synchronous or metachronous cancer before diagnosis were excluded.” However, M1 disease or synchronous cancer can be only made “during” diagnosis. How can we diagnose M1 disease or synchronous cancer “before” diagnosis?
  2. In Materials and Methods section, the authors mentioned “The pathological samples all slides retrieved from tumor) of selected patients were reviewed to confirm the presence and pattern of PNI.” Please rephrase this sentence to make it more readable.
  3. In Abstract section, the authors mentioned “only pathological N2 stage were significantly correlated with poor OS,…” In the Result section, the authors mentioned “Pathological T4 stage and pathological N2 stage correlated with OS in the univariate analysis (P < 0.05). OS rates according to different characteristics are listed in Table 2. Pathological N2 stage was the only independent prognostic factor in the multivariate analysis (P < 0.05, Table 3).” But in table 2 and 3, the “N2-3” was the same group. Why the authors only mentioned “N2” but not “N2-3” in the result section. Please make a revision in all text.
  4. In Materials and Methods section, the authors mentioned “The endpoints were tumor recurrence for time-to-recurrence (TTR) and ….” What’s the meaning of “tumor recurrence for time-to-recurrence”? Please make a more clear description and definition of TTR in this section.
  5. In Figure 1a and 1b, how many foci of IPNI and EPNI exist in each slide? Please make a description in figure caption 1.
  6. In table 2 and 3, how did the authors explain why pathological T and pathological N classification are not independent risk factors for 3-year time-to-recurrence rate in these oral cancer patients? Please discuss this point in the Discussion section.

Source

    © 2023 the Reviewer.

Content of review 3, reviewed on April 08, 2023

This topic fall within the scope of the journal and the revised manuscript is suitable and clear

Source

    © 2023 the Reviewer.

References

    Kang-Hsing, F., Chung-Jan, K., Chien-Yu, L., Shu-Hang, N., Hung-Ming, W., Chia-Hsun, H., Chih-Hua, Y., Chih-Hung, L., Chung-Kan, T., Shiang-Fu, H., Ku-Hao, F., Yu-Chien, W., Tong-Chieh, C. J., Chun-Ta, L., Li-Yu, L. 2023. Quantitative Measurement of Perineural Invasion for Prognosis Analysis of Oral Cavity Cancer Treated by Radical Surgery With or Without Adjuvant Therapy. Technology in Cancer Research & Treatment.