Content of review 1, reviewed on April 14, 2025
This work presents a new computational tool for amorphous-structured sodium-ion battery cathode materials. The work is complete and provides a new theoretical research direction. It is recommended for publication after revisions.
1.There are multiple formatting issues in the paper, such as obvious errors in citation formats, as seen on page 5.
2.The paper mentions the importance of "disorder-induced" effects but focuses on machine learning techniques in the text. Could the title emphasize this aspect?
3.Can the authors provide the positions of each element in the crystal structure and compare them with the actual crystal structure?
4.It is suggested that the authors improve the project provided on Git-hub, as the current readability is low and lacks sufficiently complete examples.
5.In DFT+U calculations, most studies use U = 4.3 eV for Fe. Why did the authors choose such a high value?
Source
© 2025 the Reviewer.
Content of review 2, reviewed on June 30, 2025
The manuscript has been modified accordingly, and this work can be accepted for publication in the journal.
Source
© 2025 the Reviewer.
References
Rasmus, C., A., P. K., M., S. M. 2025. Structural origin of disorder-induced ion conduction in NaFePO4 cathode materials. Journal of Materials Chemistry A.