Septic arthritis is a devastating complication of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, which can still occur in approximately 1% of patients despite appropriate intravenous antibiotic prophylaxis and other recommended preventative measures being undertaken. The infection is most likely secondary to the autograft becoming contaminated during harvest and preparation, introducing bacteria into the joint on insertion. Presoaking ACL grafts in 5 mg/mL vancomycin is a novel method developed to eradicate this bacterial contamination and is supported by compelling Level III evidence from multiple observational trials showing a dramatic reduction in infection rates without any evidence of increased graft failure. As such, it is time for this technique to become a universal recommendation? That said, as observational studies using a historical cohort as a comparator are at risk of various biases, Level I evidence is ultimately required for infection prophylaxis methods to be recognized as a universal recommendation in infection control guidelines. Consequently, future research endeavors on the "vancomycin wrap" should focus on randomized controlled trials, possibly nested within ACL registries.